Competing risks

In survival analysis, competing risks refer to the situation when an individual is at risk of experiencing an event that precludes the event under study to occur.

Competing risks commonly occur in studies of cause-specific mortality, as all other causes of death than the one under study might happen before the individuals “have time” to die from the cause of death of interest. For example, in studies of cancer-specific mortality among cancer patients, some individuals might die from a heart attack or stroke and not their cancer. In such cases, cancer death and non-cancer death are competing risks (or competing events).

The assumption of independent censoring is key to knowing how to run your analysis and how to interpret the results. This assumptions reads:

The time to the event of interest is conditionally independent of the time to other events precluding the event of interest to occur. 

This means that in the example above, there shall be no factors that influence both cancer and non-cancer mortality other than those factors that have been controlled for in the estimation.

If the assumption holds:

The estimated survival proportions can be interpreted as estimates of the cause-specific survival in a situation without any competing events. And, the cause-specific hazard rates provide estimates of the rates that we would observe in the absence of competing events.

If the assumption does not hold:

The survival curves will be biased and cannot be interpreted as cause-specific survival estimates. However, the cause-specific hazard rates still have a useful interpretation as the rates that are observed when competing events are present.

Importantly, there is no test of the independence assumption (as we cannot observe both the event under study and the competing event), and whether or not to do a competing risks analysis depends on the research question at hand.

Latest Resources

Specialist subjects

Real-world evidence (RWE)

Real-world evidence (RWE) Data and information that, unlike data generated in clinical trials conducted in controlled environments, has been obtained from everyday clinical practice, patient registers, or other sources outside the clinical trial setting.   RWE plays a crucial role in complementing traditional clinical trial data, providing insights into the safety, effectiveness, and overall performance […]
Read more

Videos

State-of-the-art statistical models for modern HTA

At @RedDoorAnalytics, we develop methodology and software for efficient modelling of biomarkers, measured repeatedly over time, jointly with survival outcomes, which are being increasingly used in cancer settings. We have also developed methods and software for general non-Markov multi-state survival analysis, allowing for the development of more plausible natural history models, where patient history can […]
Read more

Videos

Multilevel (hierarchical) survival models: Estimation, prediction, interpretation

Hierarchical time-to-event data is common across various research domains. In the medical field, for instance, patients are often nested within hospitals and regions, while in education, students are nested within schools. In these settings, the outcome is typically measured at the individual level, with covariates recorded at any level of the hierarchy. This hierarchical structure […]
Read more

Statistical Primers

What are competing risks?

Competing risks In survival analysis, competing risks refer to the situation when an individual is at risk of experiencing an event that precludes the event under study to occur. Competing risks commonly occur in studies of cause-specific mortality, as all other causes of death than the one under study might happen before the individuals “have […]
Read more

Statistical Primers

What is immortal time bias?

Immortal time bias Immortal time bias is a type of bias that can occur in observational research when the study design allows for a period of time during which the outcome of interest cannot occur, often referred to as “immortal time”. Simply put, immortal time bias occurs when information from a future event is incorporated into the […]
Read more

Statistical Primers

What is the proportional hazards assumption?

Proportional hazards Proportional hazards in survival analysis means that the rate at which an event of interest occurs over time for two or more groups or individuals is proportional over time. Specifically, it assumes that the hazard ratio, which represents the relative rate of an event occurring between two groups or individuals, is constant over […]
Read more

Statistical Primers

What is censoring?

Censoring refers to a situation in survival analysis where the event of interest is not observed for some of the individuals under study. In this Statistical Primer, we’ll define three types of censoring often seen in survival analysis studies. Censoring occurs when the information on the survival time is incomplete or only partially observed. Censoring […]
Read more

Statistical Primers

What is the Cox model?

The Cox model The Cox model, also known as the proportional hazards model, is a popular statistical tool used to analyse survival data. It was developed by British statistician Sir David Cox, and published in 1972. It has gained popularity largely by avoiding making parametric assumptions about the shape of the baseline rate in a […]
Read more

Statistical Primers

What is survival analysis?

Survival analysis is a statistical method used to analyse the time until an event of interest occurs. The key feature of survival analysis is that the outcome has two dimensions: – an event indicator (yes/no), and – the time spent at risk for the event All survival analyses require precise definitions of start and end of […]
Read more

Tutorials

Multivariate joint longitudinal-survival models

Joint longitudinal-survival models have been widely developed, but there are many avenues of research where they are lacking in terms of methodological development, and importantly, accessible implementations. We think merlin fills a few gaps. In this post, we’ll take a look at the extension to modelling multiple continuous longitudinal outcomes, jointly with survival. For simplicity, I’ll concentrate […]
Read more

Tutorials

Simulation and estimation of three-level survival models: IPD meta-analysis of recurrent event data

In this example I’ll look at the analysis of clustered survival data with three levels. This kind of data arises in the meta-analysis of recurrent event times, where we have observations (events or censored), k (level 1), nested within patients, j (level 2), nested within trials, i (level 3). Random intercepts The first example will […]
Read more

Tutorials

Probabilistic sensitivity analysis and survival models

Today we’re going to take a little look into probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA), and how it can be implemented within the context of survival analysis. Now PSA is used extensively in health economic modelling, where a particular parameter (or parameters) of interest, are altered or varied, to represent different scenarios and levels of variation. We […]
Read more
All Resources